Savory Butternut Squash Salad to Brighten Your Fall Table

Butternut squash salad is honestly my fall MVP. I mean, ever tried making salad in autumn and just think, “Ugh, lettuce again”? Yeah, me too. It gets old. I started craving something cozier, but still with that healthy salad vibe. That’s when butternut squash salad totally saved family dinners for me. By the way, if you’re ever stumped for how to prep a squash, my Fall Roasted Veggie Guide makes things straightforward. Or maybe you want a little more crunch? Warm Pumpkin Salad Crunch has a seriously fun twist. Trust me, this is the kind of dish that makes folks ask for seconds.

Whats in This Butternut Squash Salad?

So, what’s the deal with this butternut squash salad? Well, basically, it’s a huge mash-up of what makes fall so great-sweet roasted squash, crisp greens, tangy cheese (feta fans, hi), toasted nuts, and this zingy vinaigrette that ties the whole thing together. It’s not just leaves on a plate. Sometimes, I toss in dried cranberries if I’m feeling wild. Oh, and roasted pumpkin seeds, too, for crunch. The first time I put this together, I remember expecting it to be kind of “meh,” but it’s absolutely restaurant-level impressive. You get this awesome mix of cozy and fresh, all in one giant forkful.

If you want a salad that doesn’t just hold you over until dinner, but truly is dinner, this one can do the trick. For me, it’s a lean-in, not a side note.

Ingredient	Flavor	Texture	Why it matters
Butternut squash	Sweet	Soft, caramelized	Main star, hearty feel
Feta cheese	Tangy, creamy	Crumbly	Cuts the sweet, brings salt
Toasted nuts	Nutty, earthy	Crunchy	Puts bite in every forkful
Green leaves	Fresh, mild	Crisp	Lightens up the whole salad

How to Make Squash Salad At Home

Ok, you ready? Because this is so simple, you’ll laugh. First, you roast the butternut squash-just cut into cubes, toss in some olive oil, salt and pepper, oven magic at 400. By the way, don’t skip the roasting step… it makes everything sweeter. Once they’re golden, give them a minute to cool or your greens will wilt to mush.

I love adding the greens right to a big bowl, then dropping in the roasted squash, cheese, and nuts. Last thing: drizzle your vinaigrette and toss around. If you want to get fancy, arrange on a platter. Or just eat out of the bowl (no judgement, I do it, too). I find it’s the perfect way to clean out whatever nuts or seeds you have left in that pantry jar.

Once I made this for a potluck, everyone asked for the recipe on the spot. You don’t need to be a kitchen pro to nail it, promise.

Ingredients

Here’s what you’ll want for a really great butternut squash salad:

• 1 medium butternut squash, peeled, cubed (about 4 cups)
• 3 cups assorted leafy greens (arugula or spinach are winners)
• 1/4 cup crumbled feta or goat cheese
• 1/4 cup toasted nuts (pecans, almonds or walnuts)
• 1/4 cup dried cranberries or raisins (if you want sweet pops)
• 2 tablespoons olive oil (for roasting and vinaigrette)
• 1 tablespoon balsamic or apple cider vinegar
• Salt and pepper, to taste

Feel free to wing it a bit with what you have. No need for perfection here.

Variations

Let’s be real, no two butternut squash salads are ever the same in this house! You can swap feta for blue cheese if you like a punchy flavor. Sometimes I’ll use baby kale instead of spinach when I’m in a heartier mood. Swap the cranberries for chopped apple or pear if you want those fresh fruit vibes instead.

For some protein, toss in grilled chicken or chickpeas. I even had a friend once add roasted Brussels sprouts. Wild, but honestly? It slapped.

And hey, don’t be stingy with nuts-hazelnuts bring a whole different kind of crunch, which I absolutely love. If you’re doing dairy-free, avocado chunks instead of cheese are super creamy.

All in all: experiment and make it yours.

How to Serve

Honestly, butternut squash salad can do just about anything.

• Serve it as a side for roasted chicken or salmon. That’s my go-to combo.
• Make a meal of it with a piece of crusty bread. Perfect for lunch or light supper.
• Bring to holiday gatherings. It stands out on the buffet and gets folks talking.
• Top it with a fried egg for a cheeky brunch twist.

I’m telling you, the flexibility here is next level.

How to Make Ahead and Store

Listen, I hate soggy salad. So a little prep advice: keep your roasted squash separate until you’re ready to eat. If you’re making this for lunch boxes, pop components in divided containers. Pour dressing on just before serving.

Fridge life? This salad holds up for about two days if stored right. Any longer, and the greens just aren’t happy campers. Roasted squash, though, you can keep that in the fridge up to 4 days. Sometimes I use leftovers in soup or on pizza-waste not, want not!

Making it ahead for guests? Keep cheese and nuts separate until you toss it all together, or they’ll get pretty weird and mushy. (I learned that the hard way and spent fifteen minutes fishing out sad pecans.)

FAQs

Q: Can I use frozen butternut squash?
A: You bet. Roast it a little longer so it gets a caramelized edge. Just pat it dry first for better browning.

Q: What’s the best leafy green for this?
A: I’m loyal to arugula for the peppery kick, but baby spinach is good if you want it super gentle.

Q: Is this salad good cold or warm?
A: Both! Sometimes I even warm up the squash in the microwave before tossing-makes it all cozy.

Q: Can I make the vinaigrette ahead of time?
A: For sure. Whisk it up and stash in a jar-good for a week in the fridge.

Q: Will kids like this salad?
A: Kids shocked me… some will pick out the squash and cheese and skip the leaves, but generally yes if you skip nuts for allergy reasons.

“Made this butternut squash salad for Thanksgiving, and even my picky eater sister came back for seconds. Never thought salad could be the star of the show!” – Jamie G.

Ready to Brighten Up Your Table?

So… there you have it, straight from my kitchen to yours. This butternut squash salad hits every note: savory, sweet, a little zippy, crazy flexible. If you want more creative ideas, the Butternut Squash Salad Recipe – Love and Lemons is also a winner when you want to change things up. Looking for international inspo? Try their roasted pumpkin variations for something fresh. For an easy balance of tradition and fun, check out their How to Roast Butternut Squash guide to nail your base every time.

Whether it’s your first try or your fiftieth, this salad will keep autumn meals fresh, cozy, and surprising. Now go on, get that squash roasting and make something you’ll actually look forward to tonight!

Print